Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows Review – Spoilers!

If you don’t want to know anything, stop reading. Big spoilers ahead! Apologies for any typos, but a girl only has so much free time at work. (Yes, this is a reprint from the other day. Just want to help technorati and others find it again 🙂 )

Deathly HallowsI can’t begin to say how impressed I was at how well all the pieces fell into place in Deathly Hallows. We’d already picked up on Rowling’s trend of making small objects or bits of dialogue come into play in large ways, sometimes years later, but I was still in awe, over and over again. I enjoyed many of the trips down memory lane, from the tent we first saw at the Quidditch World Cup, to Sirius’ mirror Harry pulled out while cleaning his trunk, to the reference to what Dumbledore saw in the mirror of Erised, and heaps of other things.

I loved the characters we got to visit with again as well, even if some encounters were brief. Viktor Krum dropped by! (And Ron showed that he learned his lesson by asking Hermione to dance before Krum got the chance.) Oliver Wood turned up to fight the good fight! Just seeing his name made me grin, mostly because I adored Sean Biggerstaff in the role. Even Trelawny’s brief appearance made me laugh as she proved how useful a crystal ball can be in times of trouble.

I also loved the theme of redemption, and the way Rowling let characters we loved to hate show some true growth and humanity. Dudley. Kreatcher. Rufus Scrimgeour. Percy (we knew he’d come around!). Wormtail. Even ex’s amours Cho, Lavender, and Dean set aside whatever personal feelings they might have had to join the fight. The one person I had expected to shock us this way was Draco, and so I was even more shocked that when presented with opportunities to redeem himself, he chose cowardice instead. Draco’s mother, however, proved that she cared more about her son than anything else, so even though she didn’t act solely to protect Harry, it’s still the case that for the second time in his life, Harry was saved by motherly love. (A healthy dose of which was also doled out by Mrs. Weasley, who came roaring out of nowhere to deliver possibly the best line in the whole book.)

And Snape. I remained firmly in the “Snape is good” club, but even I was suprised at his true motivation. I just figured that although he had been drawn to the Dark Arts as a young man, he, like Draco, never had the heart of a murderer, so after his role in the death of the Potters he set about making amends as best he could. I should have known that Rowling would never do anything so common.

Now we know that Snape was “that boy” Aunt Petunia talked about. (And while it doesn’t fully redeem her, it explains more about why she was so dreadful to Harry. She was scared of magic, and jealous and hurt that she was left out of her sister’s world, and maybe even afraid to get too close to Harry in case he died young too.) We know that although Snape may have hated Harry for being so much like his father, the man who won Lily’s heart, he also couldn’t stop trying to protect Lily’s son.

Which brings me to the benefits of the worldwide InterGoogle. After I finished reading I didn’t want to immediately hop online and read a million other opinions. It was too much of a personal experience and I wasn’t ready to share. But seeing as how I finished the book in the middle of the night, I thought someone more clear headed might have caught something I didn’t, so the next day I went over to mugglenet.com. Sure enough, I was wrong in thinking I had enjoyed the last twist Rowling had to offer.

One reader asked the question, “What was the deal for all these years about Harry having his mother’s eyes? I thought they were going to play a part somehow.” I had completely forgotten about that. Luckily, a little later someone much sharper than myself simply wrote: “Re: Harry having his mother’s eyes. “Look… at… me.“” Hot damn!

Rowling really didn’t do anything without a purpose. Harry’s eyes may not have had magical qualities, but they certainly played a role. How many times must Snape have come close to turning his back on his promise? How tempting must it have been to let the child of arrogant James Potter fend for himself? But he couldn’t, because Lily was watching him. He couldn’t look at Harry without being reminded of the woman he loved, the woman he had a hand in killing, the woman he was now sacrificing his life to serve. And with his last breath, after spending the last 17 years risking his life for Harry, he asked for just one small, heartbreaking thing in return: to see those eyes one last time. And here I was thinking he was simply instructing Harry to look at his memories.

It should have been clear then, with this theme of righting wrongs, that when Hermione says the only way to repair a torn soul is through remorse, Voldemort’s death was certain. He was given the chance, refused it, and sealed his own fate.

The characters who made good were inspiring, but maybe even better were the previously “perfect” characters who were allowed to show their human weaknesses. Dumbledore had his own troubled youth, which allowed him to identify with the mistakes Snape made, and trust that he would do all he could to atone for them. Lupin was wracked with self-loathing and guilt, and came close to tearing his family apart.

And after years in Harry’s shadow, Ron finally gave in to his feelings of inadequacy and doubt, and his fear that he may never get the girl he loved, maybe even losing her to his best friend. I think the Silver Doe chapter has to be my favorite for the way it turns Ron inside out, tears him down, and then allows him to build himself up again. We see Ron at his lowest, feeling insecure about his purpose and usefulness to the group, but we also learn that he’s been fighting those feelings for ages, and that struggle speaks to his even larger strengths. Plagued with doubts, but sticking by Harry despite them, Ron is an even more loyal and courageous character than we could have guessed. (And yes, I have a wicked crush on Rupert Grint and am praying they do that scene justice in the film. Sigh. Not bloody likely.)

I also loved that some characters didn’t fit into either category. Neville, for example, just got better and better; stronger, more confident, more courageous, he took on more responsibility than I think anyone could have predicted back in year one. As good as Rowling was about all the other little details she brought back, I half expected him to ram an old bubblegum wrapper down Bellatrix’s throat, but proving that he was a true Griffyndor by pulling the sword out of the Sorting Hat to kill Nagini was even better. Oh, and his grandmother was kick-ass.

Hermione, such the rule follower in the beginning, made some of the largest sacrifices. She not only left school and broke into a bank, but she went so far as to send her parents away, and fully faced the possibility of her own death by erasing all traces of herself from their minds, to save them the pain losing her. That had to be one of the most moving acts of friendship of all. (Although Luna’s paintings of her friends were heartbreaking as well.) Ron once said Hermione should get her priorities in order, and that she did.

Oh, and that kiss? The kiss heard round the world? Exquisite. And Harry’s reaction of, “Seriously? This has to happen now? Seriously?” was one of the funniest things in the whole book, especially as I imagined Daniel Radcliffe delivering it with the same tone he used in Goblet of Fire when Ron explained how he really was the one who warned Harry about the dragons and Harry, deadpan, says, “Who… who could have possibly figured that out? That’s completely mental.” Ron and Hermione just couldn’t be too sappy or sentimental, and they couldn’t have that scene without Harry there to witness it, just as Harry couldn’t have started something with Ginny without Ron’s stamp of approval.

Finally, I love that Harry never became a murderer, that he never used anything stronger than “Expelliarmus” against Voldemort, despite Lupin’s warning. Instead he used an even stronger curse, the two words Voldemort hated most: “Tom Riddle”. Harry reduced the Dark Lord to a mere mortal, stripping him of his title and making him small, just the way Dumbledore used to do.

Once Harry understood all the mistakes and missteps Riddle made, he got what Dumbledore had been trying to explain to him: by attacking Harry and killing his parents, Voldemort took the first step in his own undoing, and Harry just had to give him enough rope to finish the job. Vanquishing Voldemort by tearing his own soul in half would have only been a half victory, and I don’t think Rowling had it in her to say goodbye and leave Harry as anything other than happy and whole.

Really, I loved everything… except the epilogue, which I’ll write about a bit later.

Advertisements

5 responses to “Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows Review – Spoilers!

  • planet pooks Deathly Hallows (w/spoilers) «

    […] Now. If you want to read a couple of reactions to Deathly Hallows that are much more thoughtful than mine, go here and here. […]

  • blurb

    Please don’t think me dense but I’m still not getting the “you have your mother’s eyes” thing. If you could deign to explain I’d appreciate it. Thanks!

    Oh, and as for my own comments – gosh – well, out of 7 books there’s so much so I’ll just go for the motherly thing: I really do wish Ms Rowling would have left Sirius alive for Harry to have in his life. Did she really have to kill off every single parental figure Harry ever loved??? I realize Ms Rowling’s own mother passed away and she was dealing with loss but really! Leave the child SOMEONE! Mr Weasley nowithstanding, Harry really could have used Sirius in his life!

  • curbsideprophecies

    Hi Blurby!

    What part of the eyes bit has you confussed? I’ll try to help. In all of the books, someone who knew Harry’s mother (Sirius, Lupin, Hagrid, whoever) told Harry, “You have your mother’s eyes.” At first it just seemed like the kind of comment every kid hears about how they resemble a parent. But after it became a repeating theme people started to guess that there was a bigger reason for it. Would Harry channel his mother through his eyes to save him once more? Were his eyes magical in some way?

    In the end we discover that they are not magical, they’re just regular old eyes, but they are the eyes that Snape fell in love with. And so when he’s dying he asks Harry to, “Look at me”, so that he can see Lily’s eyes once more. That’s it. It’s not a huge detail, it’s just a really beautiful one.

    In answer to your question, “Did she really have to kill off every single parental figure Harry ever loved?” Yes. She did. Not to be cruel or because Rowling herself was dealing with death, it’s just how coming-of-age kiddie lit and films work. Look at everything from Bambi to Huck Finn to Pippi Longstocking to the Karate Kid. Either the mentor or parent figure has to die (Heidi, The Lion King) or disappear for the bulk of the story, off to war or work (The Adventure of Natty Gann, Empire of the Sun), or the child has to create some kind of no-adult zone (Bridge to Terebithia, Peter Pan, The Secret Garden) so that the child is forced to grow up and fend for his or herself. As long as the child has an adult to rely on for guidance, the story stays stagnant (or you get Psycho).

    If Dumbledore or Sirius had lived, Harry never would have gone on his journey to discover the Horcruxes (and himself, the movie-trailer voice says). Look at Lord of the Flies, Narnia, The Never-Ending Story, all of them first get rid of the parents, otherwise the kids would be second-guessed, held back, shielded from the hard choices they must face.

    A closer example is in Order of the Phoenix, when Dumbledore shows up in the nick of time to help Harry. Dumbledore knows he can’t defeat Voldemort, but he can keep putting off the day when Harry has to do it. As long as he lived he would continue delaying the inevitable, protecting Harry out of love, until Harry was 40 and living on Dumbledore’s sofa, unemployed and playing with his Wii, never having had to become responsible for his own life. Ok, maybe without the sofa.

    Lupin also offers to come along, and for a minute I was worried that Harry might take him up on it, so it’s a good thing Rowling foiled that offer with the baby storyline. The Weasleys get to live though, and that’s fitting. They’re good surrogate parents, caring and concerned, but not powerful enough to shield Harry from his destiny. And I like to think that after a year of living with wizards who respect Harry and think of Lily and James as brave, honorable people, Aunt Petunia came around a little too 🙂

    Thanks for reading and commenting!

  • blurb

    Oh I just love the thing about the eyes now! That’s just so beautiful! And, okay, I guess I understand why all the parental figures had to die off in Harry’s life but now, answer me this….. why did poor, brand-new-baby Teddy Lupin have to lose both of HIS parents??? What does this woman have against parents?? 🙂

  • curbsideprophecies

    Yes, the deaths of Lupin and Tonks were even more upsetting because of Teddy. But I suppose that just as Harry now gets to be the parent he never had and create the loving family he always wanted, he also has a chance to be the godfather that Sirius wasn’t able to be. Tragic, but poetic. And despite its many weaknesses, the epilogue does let us know that Teddy was well cared for and raised to be like Harry’s own son, always at his house and surrounded by family.

    Personally, I think it’s a good sign that Rowling wrote a book that has enough “I can’t believe she did that!” moments to keep people dissecting it and re-reading it and arguing about it for years to come. I understand why people wish that the book had ended with “And they all lived…”, but a “happily ever after” story isn’t nearly as real or satisfying. I mean, how much can you really say about Charlie and the Chocolate Factory?

    Happy Reading,
    Lisa

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: